Only Little Once Nutcracker Sugar Plum Fairy Mercari The Sugar Plum Fairy May Be a Cultural Icon, but Who Is She Really? Pointe Magazine Did you guess that the Sugarplum Fairy is the only character with a costume change in Act II of George Balanchine's The Nutcracker? If so, you guessed correctly. She first appears in The Nutcracker Ballet Tutu Pro Sugar Plum Fairy I XS Plum What Does an Angel See in Her Future? Maybe a Sugarplum Fairy. The New York Times